Abstract:
In the Brazilian educational context, teaching with experimental activity has been
highlighted since the New School with repercussions on educational policy and
didactic practices, currently gaining prominence in the National Curricular Common
Base. The focus of this research is the conception of experimental and investigative
activity, specifically with regard to science teaching. Vygotsky's cultural-historical
conception of human development and Davydov theory of developmental teaching
value the student's investigative activity and experimentation in teaching with a view
to forming concepts of a dialectical nature in order to enable student learning through
the formation of dialectical concepts. In this way, the student can reach a dialectical
understanding of scientific phenomena, developing the ability to analyze the natural
and social world, going beyond an empirical and utilitarian vision. Based on this
theoretical framework, this research focused on the teaching of natural sciences,
seeking to answer: in the scientific literature in the area of education, how have
experimental and/or investigative activities been approached in natural science
classes in basic education? What is the concept of experimental activity present in
this literature? What content or discipline do they refer to? Has the historical-cultural
theoretical framework been used in these researches? The general objective was to
analyze and discuss how experimental and/or investigative activities in the teaching
of natural sciences have been addressed in educational policies and in articles in
national scientific journals. The specific objectives were: to present and discuss the
contributions of Vygotsky's and Davydov theories regarding the role of scientific
concepts for the development of students; to analyze the Brazilian educational policy
regarding the teaching of natural sciences in basic education, from the National
Curriculum Parameters to the National Curricular Common Base; to identify the
concepts of experimental and/or investigative activity present in scientific articles and
to analyze, in the light of Vigotsky and Davydov theories, their contributions to the
development of students. The methodology consisted of: document analysis of the
National Curriculum Parameters for science teaching and the National Curricular
Common Base; integrative literature review, covering articles published in journals in
the field of science education, published between 2010 and 2020. The results of the
analyzes show that in pcn and bncc experimental activities are not aimed at broad
student psychic development. The analyzed scientific articles predominated research
referring to high school; for the most part, experimental activities are developed with
the aim of proving/verifying and validating theories and laws related to contents of
physics, chemistry, science, with few studies in the area of biology; there is a
prevalence of constructivist and empiricist-inductivist conceptions of experimental
activities, with greater weight in the practical-empirical and utilitarian understanding
of scientific phenomena. On the other hand, the historical-cultural and developmental
teaching concepts were not very expressive. In most experiments, the emphasis is
only on observing phenomena and performing procedures as a condition for
acquiring knowledge, not valuing the formation of concepts. It is concluded that it is
necessary to overcome the concepts of teaching with experimental activity that are
predominant today because they do not contribute to the formation of concepts and
expansion of student development. It is considered important to promote studies on
science teaching with experimental and investigative activity in the historical-cultural
perspective and developmental teaching, due to the potential that these theories
present to promote students' awareness, autonomy and creativity in a critical
perspective, beyond of a teaching focused on the constitution of the student as an
adequate subject to neoliberalism, in particular.